Breed comparison

Which breed should you hatch? 30 breeds compared

Egg production, egg color, temperament and hardiness for 10 chicken, 10 duck and 10 quail breeds, side by side, with our picks for every goal.

On this page
  1. Best breeds by goal
  2. Chicken breeds compared
  3. Duck breeds compared
  4. Quail breeds compared
  5. Incubation time by bird type
  6. Frequently asked questions
⚡ Quick answer

For the most eggs, hatch White Leghorns (280–320 a year), Khaki Campbell ducks (250–340) or Coturnix quail (250–300, laying at 6–8 weeks old). For beginners and families, Buff Orpingtons, Plymouth Rocks and Australorps are calm, cold-hardy and reliable. For colorful eggs, choose Easter Eggers (blue/green) or Marans (chocolate brown).

Best breeds by goal

Your goalChickenDuckQuail
Most eggsLeghornKhaki CampbellCoturnix
Beginners & kidsBuff OrpingtonPekinCoturnix
Cold wintersAustralorp, Plymouth RockBlue SwedishCoturnix (sheltered)
Hot climatesLeghornIndian RunnerCoturnix (shade)
Colorful eggsEaster Egger, MaransCayuga, AnconaAll (speckled)
Quiet neighborsHens only (no rooster)MuscovyCoturnix hens
MeatDual-purpose: Plymouth RockPekin, MuscovyJumbo, Texas A&M

Chicken breeds compared

All chicken eggs incubate for 21 days at 99.5°F (bantams 20–21). Choose on climate and temperament first, egg count second. A calm hen that lays 250 eggs is a better backyard bird than a flighty one that lays 300.

Egg counts are typical first-year ranges for well-fed hens with good daylight; production drops 10–20% a year after year two.
PhotoBreedEggs per yearEgg colorTemperamentClimateBest for
Rhode Island RedRhode Island Red250–300BrownAssertiveCold-hardyReliable layer for any climate
White LeghornWhite Leghorn280–320WhiteFlightyHeat-tolerantMaximum egg count
Buff OrpingtonBuff Orpington200–280Light brownVery calmVery cold-hardyFamilies, broody hens
Plymouth Rock (Barred)Plymouth Rock (Barred)200–280BrownDocileCold-hardyBeginners, dual-purpose
Black AustralorpBlack Australorp250–300BrownFriendlyAll climatesTop brown-egg layer
Speckled SussexSpeckled Sussex250–275Cream to light brownGentleCold-hardyFree-ranging, foraging
WelsummerWelsummer160–200Dark speckled brownAlertModerateStriking dark eggs
Easter EggerEaster Egger200–280Blue, green or pinkSweetVariableColorful egg basket
BarnevelderBarnevelder150–200Dark brownQuietModerateCalm, ornamental flock
MaransMarans150–200Chocolate brownReservedCold-hardyDarkest eggs

Hatching chickens? Follow the 21-day incubation calendar.

Duck breeds compared

Most duck eggs hatch in 28 days. Muscovy take 35 days because they're a separate species. Duck eggs need higher humidity than chicken eggs (see the duck incubation guide).

Duck egg counts vary widely by strain: production lines lay far more than exhibition lines.
PhotoBreedEggs per yearEgg colorTemperamentSizeBest for
Khaki CampbellKhaki Campbell250–340WhiteActive foragerMediumMost duck eggs
PekinPekin150–200WhiteCalmLargeMeat, friendly pets
Indian RunnerIndian Runner200–300White to pale greenUpright, busyLightPest control, laying
Blue SwedishBlue Swedish100–180White to gray-greenQuietHeavyHardy dual-purpose
CayugaCayuga100–150Gray to charcoal (early season)CalmMediumDark eggs, ornamental
Buff Orpington duckBuff Orpington duck150–220White to tintedDocileMediumDual-purpose
AnconaAncona210–280White, cream or blueFriendlyMediumHardy layer
MuscovyMuscovy60–120White to creamQuiet (hisses, rarely quacks)LargeQuiet, broody, meat
MagpieMagpie220–290White to blue-greenDocileLightGood layer, foraging
SaxonySaxony190–240WhiteGentleLargeDual-purpose, calm

Quail breeds compared

Coturnix quail hatch in 17–18 days and start laying at 6–8 weeks, which makes them the fastest egg layers you can hatch. Bobwhite take 23–24 days and are usually raised as game birds. Check your state's rules before keeping them.

Pharaoh, Texas A&M, Italian, Tibetan, Golden Manchurian, English White and Red are all color or size varieties of the same species, Coturnix japonica, so they incubate and lay alike.
PhotoBreedEggs per yearEgg colorTemperamentGrowthBest for
Coturnix (Japanese)Coturnix (Japanese)250–300SpeckledDocileFast (lays at 6–8 wks)Fastest eggs, small spaces
Northern BobwhiteNorthern Bobwhite100–150WhiteFlightySlowGame birds (permit may be required)
Button quailButton quailLow (pet)Speckled, tinySkittishFastPets, aviaries
Pharaoh CoturnixPharaoh Coturnix250–300SpeckledFriendlyFastClassic wild-type Coturnix
Texas A&M CoturnixTexas A&M Coturnix250–300SpeckledQuietFast, heavyMeat (white plumage)
Italian CoturnixItalian Coturnix250–300SpeckledDocileFastColor variety
Tibetan CoturnixTibetan Coturnix250–300SpeckledShyFastColor variety
Golden Manchurian CoturnixGolden Manchurian Coturnix250–300SpeckledSkittishFast, largerMeat and eggs
English White CoturnixEnglish White Coturnix250–300SpeckledCalmFastClean-plucking meat bird
Red CoturnixRed Coturnix250–300SpeckledBoldFastColor variety

Ready to hatch quail? Read the quail incubation guide.

Incubation time by bird type

BirdDays to hatchLockdown
Chicken21Day 18
Bantam chicken20–21Day 17–18
Duck (all but Muscovy)28Day 25
Muscovy35Day 32
Coturnix quail17–18Day 15
Bobwhite quail23–24Day 21

Turn any set date into a full schedule with the hatch date calculator.

Frequently asked questions

Which chicken breed lays the most eggs?

The White Leghorn, at roughly 280–320 white eggs a year in its first laying season. Commercial hybrids such as ISA Browns can match it, but they don't breed true, so eggs from hybrid hens won't hatch into the same bird.

What is the best chicken breed for beginners?

Buff Orpingtons, Plymouth Rocks and Australorps. All three are calm, easy to handle, cold-hardy and lay 200–300 brown eggs a year. Orpingtons also go broody readily, which is useful if you want a hen to hatch eggs for you later.

Which duck lays the most eggs?

The Khaki Campbell, with production strains laying 250–340 eggs a year. Indian Runners, Magpies and Anconas are also strong layers. Pekins and Muscovies are kept more for meat and lay far fewer.

How fast do quail start laying?

Coturnix quail usually start laying at 6–8 weeks old, which is faster than any other poultry. Bobwhite quail take about 16 weeks or more and lay seasonally.

Are Pharaoh, Italian and Tibetan quail different species?

No. Pharaoh, Italian, Tibetan, Golden Manchurian, English White, Red and Texas A&M are all varieties of Coturnix quail (Coturnix japonica). They differ in feather color or size but incubate for the same 17–18 days and lay similarly.

Incubator Guide Editorial Team

We write species-specific hatching guides checked against university extension and 4-H embryology resources, and we re-verify every product recommendation for availability before each update. How we research & test →

Get hatch-day reminders & new guides

One short email when we publish a new guide or re-check incubator stock. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.